top of page

Hope is a chore

Writer: Wren
Wren
6 days ago
6 min read

I shoot awake at 3 am with chest tightness, a sensation that I've never experienced before. It scares me, jolting my nervous system online to begin the work of longer-term worrying. The mild panic attack compounds on the tight chest, sending both into deeper states of severity. My husband drives us to the ER, my body shaking and heaving with sobs in the passenger seat. He tries to explain to the front desk worker what I could only say in a few words between spasms, and they ask us to have a seat. The alarm grows louder. Have a seat? While I'm dying? Another person in the waiting room gets seen before me - from my vantage point, they have no visible symptoms of emergency. I wonder if I have to start convulsing on the floor before someone actually helps me.


And I'm not thinking about this in the moment...but this is where collectivism and community care go out the window. The animal brain takes over. I need to be seen and heard now.


Thankfully this scenario is hypothetical for me, but it isn’t for plenty of people. It shows me two things. One, we never have the full picture of the collective (I, in fact, wasn’t dying of a panic attack, and the person who went first was experiencing early symptoms of a stroke). Two, my animal brain was never going to make that call fairly. Something else had to, and it did.


Two large, white farm dogs stand in front of a barn at sunset, one of them laying on the ground and the other nuzzling a tabby cat.

And now for a real scenario: the one that occurred on the day after the 2026 midterms, where millions of people across the country declared a "blue tsunami" in the wake of the largest Democratic senate flip in over 30 years - where we beheld our first Black female and Native American female governors, where some states were seeing blue for the first time since the Great Depression. Social media was flooded with "libbed out" memes that were admittedly hilarious, keeping me giggling and kicking my feet on the couch through a sick day. It was genuinely the single greatest sense of relief in the last several years, like a giant collective sigh. I could begin to imagine a real way forward, how we could be one day.


And then, after the hype died down, I remembered how we are - how we tend to be when things get dicey and complicated and nuanced. Because the hard part is only just starting, after all. All the wishlist items from Project 2025 haven't taken full effect. These new Democratic leaders aren't yet in their seats and, even when they are, may very well follow down the same path they have for quite a long time - one that may get things accomplished, but all too quietly so that citizens barely notice. One that underdelivers, or worse, goes back on their word. One that doesn't actually align with what the collective wants and needs. But what does any of that really matter? We showed up, we voted, and we won. People feel as if they've done their part, so now the attention drifts not after the work is completed, but before it even begins.


This happens because, as much as we may claim to love community and desire a "village" to support us, we are still self-serving. We did our civic duty, and now the work is done. It certainly doesn't help to steep in a culture that actively incentivizes living so individualistically, with all the commodities we can access with the touch of a button, delivered to our doorsteps. By many standards, we don't actually need to interact at all. Many of us opt to participate in IRL connection as little as possible. For that reason, we still mostly care about what touches us - what happens right in front of our eyes. Gas prices, groceries for the family, our own waiting room experience are all more important on the day-to-day than the severe, agriculture-destabilizing droughts in Arkansas or the fact that Gaza doesn't have a single fully-functioning hospital.


I'll be the first to say, as much as it hurts, that this makes perfect sense. It's human nature. And it's why I so often find it hard to hope that things could really be different this time around, even with historic progressive changes to the Democratic Party.


But “it’s human nature” can’t be where we stop, because thinking about the ER taught me something: human nature isn’t the whole story when there is a system built to override the instinct. Politics has no triage nurse. The only thing standing in for one is us: our boring, sustained, unglamorous attention, which is exactly what drifts the moment we feel we’ve won. So not only do we need to keep watching and caring, but we need to be specific about what we hold the people we just elected to.


I'll start: Not only should a party member never accept AIPAC money, they shouldn't accept money from its individual donors either. It's a loophole many politicians use and hide behind, and it's one example of infinite others that shows how a pledge can be real (take Abdul El-Sayed's refusal of those funds) or hollow (my unfortunate Democratic Senate victor, Mark Warner, who has accepted nearly $900,000 through AIPAC and other pro-Israel groups), and how we are still obligated to read the fine print long after the hype dies down. If we want change, that's the only way to sustain it.


Accountability doesn't have a party assignment, and I'm sorry (not really) to Hakeem Jeffries, but he's wrong about Americans not valuing it. We deserve representatives and leaders who will challenge their own party and scrutinize policy regardless of political affiliation, especially when it comes to those that entertain the negotiation of human rights to their own benefit. We deserve it, and we will not get it simply because the Senate flipped. We must fight for it relentlessly. It asks a lot of us, but again, it's the only sure path to make sure we stay headed in the right direction.


And as a people, it's long past time to utilize the same fire that our leaders have been, but perhaps with more decorum. We need a lot that we're not getting, and asking nicely of the people who can provide, but instead choose to spend billions on illegal wars and golden ballrooms, who spend more time talking lewdly about other politicians' physiques than about current national crises is never going to grant us any of it. But rather than stooping to the same lows, as many have suggested Democrats need to do, we focus on sustained, specific, low-drama pressure. Intense friction rather than explosion. Spectacle gets people engaged, but engagement driven by outrage burns everyone out and rewards whoever is loudest. No one really wins, and we just keep circling the drain.


Again I think of the ER. Though our medical system has an endless list of its own problems, one thing it's good at is determining severity of need in the moment, on the ground. The consistent goal is for a system where attention doesn’t depend on a crisis, and the institution works whether or not anyone is watching. The same goes for politics - please, God, no more "can you believe what he said in the press conference today?" And though the net-positive effect of having outlandishly evil cartoon-like villains running the show for the last decade is a major uptick in participation from the rest of us, I'd still vote to make politics boring again.


It's a tall order, I know - especially after the Trump era. I fear that the vitriol he and his cabinet have gotten away with for so long has created a generations-long ripple effect of nastiness and the normalization of it, not just in government, but in daily life. But it wasn't even twenty years ago when John McCain swiftly rebuked racist comments made about his opponent, Barack Obama, in public settings for the country to witness. Where he proudly acknowledged that while, sure, they had fundamental disagreements of how to run the country, they were still great colleagues and collaborators to each other. The respect was palpable in a way that doesn't feel possible anymore. And yet I still hope for a future where it is again.


Maybe this kind of politics won't garner the same attention from the rest of us that it does in 2026. With our short attention spans and constant need for gossip and outrage, it seems likely that that would be the outcome. But I'd also like to give us a little more credit, because we have fought back on a fascist-leaning system that clearly isn't working for the vast majority. We have elected new leaders that, only a year ago, were slated "too radical" even by liberal opinion to ever win major seats. We are seeing more engagement in elections, more care into issues that don't directly affect us. Maybe we're not entirely self-serving - just perhaps forgetful.


So I land myself in that hypothetical waiting room seat a final time; I don't know what's happening to the people around me, but I believe in the system enough to shove down my internal screaming and allow the professionals in the room to do their job. If they don't, of course, I'll cry out for help before taking a turn for the worst. There need be no additional drama here, because it won't help anyone. I allow the system to work as intended, even if it scares me - because ultimately I know that hope only survives on trust, and that trust survives on a mutual understanding, of mutual care. I, too, play a role in how well this whole thing works.

Comments


  • Youtube
  • Facebook
  • Threads
  • Instagram

Subscribe to Lead to Gold

Yay! 🤍

©2024 by Lead to Gold.

bottom of page